Guideline appraisal with AGREE II: Systematic review of the current evidence on how users handle the 2 overall assessments
Publication Date
March 30, 2017
Authors
Wiebke Hoffmann Eßer, Ulrich Siering, Edmund A. M. Neugebauer, Anne Catharina Brockhaus, et al
Volume
12
Issue
3
Pages
e0174831
DOI
https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0174831
Publisher URL
http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0174831
Scopus
85016780770
Mendeley
http://www.mendeley.com/research/guideline-appraisal-agree-ii-systematic-review-current-evidence-users-handle-2-overall-assessments
Events
Loading … Spinner

Mendeley | Further Information

{"title"=>"Guideline appraisal with AGREE II: Systematic review of the current evidence on how users handle the 2 overall assessments", "type"=>"journal", "authors"=>[{"first_name"=>"Wiebke", "last_name"=>"Hoffmann-Eßer", "scopus_author_id"=>"55939373800"}, {"first_name"=>"Ulrich", "last_name"=>"Siering", "scopus_author_id"=>"23991462900"}, {"first_name"=>"Edmund A.M.", "last_name"=>"Neugebauer", "scopus_author_id"=>"7101640481"}, {"first_name"=>"Anne Catharina", "last_name"=>"Brockhaus", "scopus_author_id"=>"56029094500"}, {"first_name"=>"Ulrike", "last_name"=>"Lampert", "scopus_author_id"=>"6506781943"}, {"first_name"=>"Michaela", "last_name"=>"Eikermann", "scopus_author_id"=>"49862951300"}], "year"=>2017, "source"=>"PLoS ONE", "identifiers"=>{"sgr"=>"85016780770", "pmid"=>"28358870", "pui"=>"615074583", "isbn"=>"1111111111", "scopus"=>"2-s2.0-85016780770", "doi"=>"10.1371/journal.pone.0174831", "issn"=>"19326203"}, "id"=>"027606c6-7347-32ba-8b4e-cfa2867a1671", "abstract"=>"Introduction: The Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation (AGREE) II instrument is the most commonly used guideline appraisal tool. It includes 23 appraisal criteria (items) organized within 6 domains and 2 overall assessments (1. overall guideline quality; 2. recommendation for use). The aim of this systematic review was twofold. Firstly, to investigate how often AGREE II users conduct the 2 overall assessments. Secondly, to investigate the influence of the 6 domain scores on each of the 2 overall assessments. Materials and methods: A systematic bibliographic search was conducted for publications reporting guideline appraisals with AGREE II. The impact of the 6 domain scores on the overall assessment of guideline quality was examined using a multiple linear regression model. Their impact on the recommendation for use (possible answers: “yes”, “yes, with modifications”, “no”) was examined using a multinomial regression model. Results: 118 relevant publications including 1453 guidelines were identified. 77.1% of the publications reported results for at least one overall assessment, but only 32.2% reported results for both overall assessments. The results of the regression analyses showed a statistically significant influence of all domains on overall guideline quality, with Domain 3 (rigour of development) having the strongest influence. For the recommendation for use, the results showed a significant influence of Domains 3 to 5 (“yes” vs. “no”) and Domains 3 and 5 (“yes, with modifications” vs. “no”). Conclusions: The 2 overall assessments of AGREE II are underreported by guideline assessors. Domains 3 and 5 have the strongest influence on the results of the 2 overall assessments, while the other domains have a varying influence. Within a normative approach, our findings could be used as guidance for weighting individual domains in AGREE II to make the overall assessments more objective. Alternatively, a stronger content analysis of the individual domains could clarify their importance in terms of guideline quality. Moreover, AGREE II should require users to transparently present how they conducted the assessments.", "link"=>"http://www.mendeley.com/research/guideline-appraisal-agree-ii-systematic-review-current-evidence-users-handle-2-overall-assessments", "reader_count"=>23, "reader_count_by_academic_status"=>{"Unspecified"=>3, "Student > Doctoral Student"=>2, "Researcher"=>2, "Student > Ph. D. Student"=>2, "Other"=>5, "Student > Master"=>4, "Student > Bachelor"=>3, "Lecturer > Senior Lecturer"=>1, "Professor"=>1}, "reader_count_by_user_role"=>{"Unspecified"=>3, "Student > Doctoral Student"=>2, "Researcher"=>2, "Student > Ph. D. Student"=>2, "Other"=>5, "Student > Master"=>4, "Student > Bachelor"=>3, "Lecturer > Senior Lecturer"=>1, "Professor"=>1}, "reader_count_by_subject_area"=>{"Unspecified"=>6, "Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology"=>1, "Nursing and Health Professions"=>2, "Medicine and Dentistry"=>8, "Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmaceutical Science"=>3, "Sports and Recreations"=>1, "Computer Science"=>1, "Decision Sciences"=>1}, "reader_count_by_subdiscipline"=>{"Medicine and Dentistry"=>{"Medicine and Dentistry"=>8}, "Decision Sciences"=>{"Decision Sciences"=>1}, "Sports and Recreations"=>{"Sports and Recreations"=>1}, "Computer Science"=>{"Computer Science"=>1}, "Nursing and Health Professions"=>{"Nursing and Health Professions"=>2}, "Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology"=>{"Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology"=>1}, "Unspecified"=>{"Unspecified"=>6}, "Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmaceutical Science"=>{"Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmaceutical Science"=>3}}, "reader_count_by_country"=>{"Brazil"=>1}, "group_count"=>1}

Scopus | Further Information

{"@_fa"=>"true", "link"=>[{"@_fa"=>"true", "@ref"=>"self", "@href"=>"https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/85016780770"}, {"@_fa"=>"true", "@ref"=>"author-affiliation", "@href"=>"https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/85016780770?field=author,affiliation"}, {"@_fa"=>"true", "@ref"=>"scopus", "@href"=>"https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?partnerID=HzOxMe3b&scp=85016780770&origin=inward"}, {"@_fa"=>"true", "@ref"=>"scopus-citedby", "@href"=>"https://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.uri?partnerID=HzOxMe3b&scp=85016780770&origin=inward"}], "prism:url"=>"https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/85016780770", "dc:identifier"=>"SCOPUS_ID:85016780770", "eid"=>"2-s2.0-85016780770", "dc:title"=>"Guideline appraisal with AGREE II: Systematic review of the current evidence on how users handle the 2 overall assessments", "dc:creator"=>"Hoffmann-Eßer W.", "prism:publicationName"=>"PLoS ONE", "prism:eIssn"=>"19326203", "prism:volume"=>"12", "prism:issueIdentifier"=>"3", "prism:pageRange"=>nil, "prism:coverDate"=>"2017-03-01", "prism:coverDisplayDate"=>"March 2017", "prism:doi"=>"10.1371/journal.pone.0174831", "citedby-count"=>"28", "affiliation"=>[{"@_fa"=>"true", "affilname"=>"Institut für Qualität und Wirtschaftlichkeit im Gesundheitswesen", "affiliation-city"=>"Koln", "affiliation-country"=>"Germany"}, {"@_fa"=>"true", "affilname"=>"Universität Witten/Herdecke", "affiliation-city"=>"Witten", "affiliation-country"=>"Germany"}], "pubmed-id"=>"28358870", "prism:aggregationType"=>"Journal", "subtype"=>"ar", "subtypeDescription"=>"Article", "article-number"=>"e0174831", "source-id"=>"10600153309", "openaccess"=>"1", "openaccessFlag"=>true}

Counter

  • {"month"=>"3", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"30", "xml_views"=>"8", "html_views"=>"269"}
  • {"month"=>"4", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"43", "xml_views"=>"4", "html_views"=>"181"}
  • {"month"=>"5", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"81", "xml_views"=>"2", "html_views"=>"79"}
  • {"month"=>"6", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"15", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"93"}
  • {"month"=>"7", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"18", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"79"}
  • {"month"=>"8", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"46", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"94"}
  • {"month"=>"9", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"38", "xml_views"=>"2", "html_views"=>"142"}
  • {"month"=>"10", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"24", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"171"}
  • {"month"=>"11", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"24", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"242"}
  • {"month"=>"12", "year"=>"2017", "pdf_views"=>"22", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"217"}
  • {"month"=>"1", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"37", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"116"}
  • {"month"=>"2", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"37", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"122"}
  • {"month"=>"3", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"67", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"166"}
  • {"month"=>"4", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"61", "xml_views"=>"2", "html_views"=>"153"}
  • {"month"=>"5", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"56", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"130"}
  • {"month"=>"6", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"59", "xml_views"=>"5", "html_views"=>"90"}
  • {"month"=>"7", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"57", "xml_views"=>"3", "html_views"=>"109"}
  • {"month"=>"8", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"86", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"118"}
  • {"month"=>"9", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"38", "xml_views"=>"3", "html_views"=>"144"}
  • {"month"=>"10", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"90", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"167"}
  • {"month"=>"11", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"76", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"179"}
  • {"month"=>"12", "year"=>"2018", "pdf_views"=>"8", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"71"}
  • {"month"=>"1", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"68", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"67"}
  • {"month"=>"2", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"72", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"68"}
  • {"month"=>"3", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"88", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"104"}
  • {"month"=>"4", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"12", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"182"}
  • {"month"=>"5", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"16", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"74"}
  • {"month"=>"6", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"20", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"78"}
  • {"month"=>"7", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"21", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"67"}
  • {"month"=>"8", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"18", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"49"}
  • {"month"=>"9", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"17", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"73"}
  • {"month"=>"10", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"29", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"62"}
  • {"month"=>"11", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"16", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"90"}
  • {"month"=>"12", "year"=>"2019", "pdf_views"=>"16", "xml_views"=>"2", "html_views"=>"40"}
  • {"month"=>"1", "year"=>"2020", "pdf_views"=>"12", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"32"}
  • {"month"=>"2", "year"=>"2020", "pdf_views"=>"13", "xml_views"=>"2", "html_views"=>"50"}
  • {"month"=>"3", "year"=>"2020", "pdf_views"=>"17", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"41"}
  • {"month"=>"4", "year"=>"2020", "pdf_views"=>"57", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"76"}
  • {"month"=>"5", "year"=>"2020", "pdf_views"=>"71", "xml_views"=>"1", "html_views"=>"42"}
  • {"month"=>"6", "year"=>"2020", "pdf_views"=>"1", "xml_views"=>"0", "html_views"=>"9"}

PMC Usage Stats

  • {"unique-ip"=>"16", "full-text"=>"16", "pdf"=>"8", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"3", "supp-data"=>"0", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"4"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"27", "full-text"=>"29", "pdf"=>"8", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"0", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"5"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"27", "full-text"=>"27", "pdf"=>"10", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"2", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"6"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"20", "full-text"=>"20", "pdf"=>"7", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"4", "supp-data"=>"2", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"7"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"42", "full-text"=>"48", "pdf"=>"13", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"4", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"8"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"62", "full-text"=>"64", "pdf"=>"11", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"0", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"9"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"63", "full-text"=>"62", "pdf"=>"12", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"3", "supp-data"=>"11", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"10"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"82", "full-text"=>"91", "pdf"=>"29", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"2", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"11"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"30", "full-text"=>"32", "pdf"=>"6", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"2", "supp-data"=>"5", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2017", "month"=>"12"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"58", "full-text"=>"64", "pdf"=>"9", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"3", "supp-data"=>"0", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"1"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"7", "full-text"=>"8", "pdf"=>"0", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"0", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"2"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"110", "full-text"=>"124", "pdf"=>"12", "abstract"=>"0", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"3", "supp-data"=>"8", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"3"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"69", "full-text"=>"81", "pdf"=>"22", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"9", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"1"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"98", "full-text"=>"115", "pdf"=>"12", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"5", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"9"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"65", "full-text"=>"77", "pdf"=>"5", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"2", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"12"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"131", "full-text"=>"150", "pdf"=>"15", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"14", "cited-by"=>"1", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"11"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"85", "full-text"=>"98", "pdf"=>"15", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"17", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"4"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"78", "full-text"=>"86", "pdf"=>"16", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"2", "cited-by"=>"2", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"5"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"56", "full-text"=>"60", "pdf"=>"5", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"1", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"6"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"63", "full-text"=>"69", "pdf"=>"3", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"18", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"7"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"68", "full-text"=>"78", "pdf"=>"11", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"3", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"8"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"74", "full-text"=>"92", "pdf"=>"14", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"1", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2018", "month"=>"10"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"92", "full-text"=>"102", "pdf"=>"12", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"4", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"2"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"193", "full-text"=>"223", "pdf"=>"23", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"3", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"3"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"202", "full-text"=>"234", "pdf"=>"38", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"4", "supp-data"=>"5", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"4"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"146", "full-text"=>"160", "pdf"=>"17", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"3", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"5"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"132", "full-text"=>"159", "pdf"=>"17", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"4", "cited-by"=>"0", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"8"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"202", "full-text"=>"229", "pdf"=>"25", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"2", "supp-data"=>"6", "cited-by"=>"1", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"9"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"222", "full-text"=>"241", "pdf"=>"25", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"1", "supp-data"=>"5", "cited-by"=>"1", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"10"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"132", "full-text"=>"154", "pdf"=>"16", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"3", "cited-by"=>"1", "year"=>"2019", "month"=>"12"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"214", "full-text"=>"267", "pdf"=>"20", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"5", "cited-by"=>"2", "year"=>"2020", "month"=>"2"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"246", "full-text"=>"303", "pdf"=>"24", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"4", "cited-by"=>"1", "year"=>"2020", "month"=>"3"}
  • {"unique-ip"=>"203", "full-text"=>"248", "pdf"=>"30", "scanned-summary"=>"0", "scanned-page-browse"=>"0", "figure"=>"0", "supp-data"=>"2", "cited-by"=>"1", "year"=>"2020", "month"=>"4"}
Loading … Spinner
There are currently no alerts